The social media embargo for James Gunn’s highly anticipated Superman has lifted, and the first wave of critical reactions has arrived. As the inaugural film in a rebooted DC Universe under the new leadership of James Gunn and Peter Safran, expectations have been sky-high.
Critics are calling it a “thrilling start” to the new era, with Gunn blending fresh energy with the character’s classic roots. The film marks a significant tonal shift for DC on screen, attempting to recenter its narrative around heart, optimism, and grounded moral questions.
Stellar Performances Shine Despite Divided Opinions on Storytelling, Tone, and Visual Priorities
Among the most glowing reviews comes from film critic Bryan Sudfield, who describes Superman as a “bold yet faithful” reimagining of the iconic hero. He applauds Gunn for maintaining Superman’s core values while injecting modern sensibility and flair.
David Corenswet’s portrayal is being praised as sincere and strong, effectively balancing heroism with humanity. Entertainment journalist Brandon Davis echoed these sentiments, emphasizing the palpable chemistry between Corenswet’s Superman and Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane, which he claims is a key driver of the story’s emotional resonance.
James Gunn’s Superman Draws Praise for Performances and Heart, Though Critics Split on Story and StyleHowever, not all reactions were universally positive. Film critic Peter Howell offered a more skeptical take, criticizing the film’s emphasis on visual spectacle over storytelling depth. He described the plot as style-driven, suggesting that Gunn struggles with narrative clarity.
While Howell found Corenswet’s Superman charming, he felt the character lacked gravitas, and Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor didn’t quite strike the right villainous tone. Interestingly, he noted that the standout character was the superdog Krypto, who reportedly steals every scene he’s in.
A Philosophical Superman Anchored in Morality, American Ideals, and Hopeful Cinematic Revival
Gunn has emphasized that Superman is about more than just superhero action; it’s a philosophical story rooted in American identity and moral values. He frames Superman as an immigrant figure, exploring themes of morality, kindness, and ideological conflict—particularly between Superman’s unwavering pacifism and Lois Lane’s more pragmatic worldview.
These thematic undercurrents reflect a broader ambition to make the film relevant beyond its comic book origins, providing audiences with thought-provoking content underneath its spectacle.
Final reactions remain mixed but largely optimistic. Critics like Rachel Leishman and Grace Randolph call it a heartfelt, hopeful take that brings joy back to the Superman legacy, with Randolph even declaring it the best Superman movie to date. Still, some reviewers cite a convoluted plot that may hinder its overall impact.
Despite this, performances across the board—especially from Corenswet, Brosnahan, and Hoult—have garnered widespread acclaim. As Superman prepares for its July 11 release, the film seems poised to reignite excitement for DC’s cinematic future, even if it doesn’t soar flawlessly.