Chip and Joanna Gaines Face Faith-Based Backlash Over LGBTQ+ Inclusion in New Show Back to the Frontier

Former HGTV stars Chip and Joanna Gaines are facing criticism from conservative Christian groups over their new reality show, Back to the Frontier, which features a same-sex couple and their children. The show, which premiered on HBO Max on July 10, follows three American families as they attempt to live like 1880s homesteaders.

The Gaineses, known for their strong Christian beliefs and family-friendly content on their Magnolia Network, serve as executive producers. The inclusion of two Texas dads and their 10-year-old twin sons, born via surrogate, has sparked significant backlash online and in religious communities.

Christian Leaders Condemn Show, Accuse Gaineses of Abandoning Biblical Marriage and Values

The controversy erupted after clips of the show circulated on social media, drawing fire from several conservative Christian leaders and organizations. Many critics accused the Gaineses of endorsing a lifestyle they consider contrary to biblical teachings. Reverend Franklin Graham, head of the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, expressed disappointment, stating that promoting a same-sex relationship “is in itself sin.” He emphasized that while Christians are called to love others, they must still uphold God’s truth as defined in the Bible.

Additional criticism came from Ed Vitagliano of the American Family Association, who said he was saddened by what he viewed as a departure from the Gaineses’ previous stance on traditional marriage. He noted the couple’s influence within the evangelical community and questioned why they would now promote what he called an “unbiblical view” of sexuality and family. Vitagliano suggested that the decision could confuse and mislead other Christians who have followed the Gaineses for their values and content.

Chip Gaines Urges Compassion Over Judgment Amid Faith-Based Backlash to New Show

In response to the online uproar, Chip Gaines took to social media to defend the show and call for understanding. He criticized the modern Christian tendency to judge harshly rather than listen and empathize. Referring to the backlash, he noted the irony that many nonbelievers experience hate for the first time when confronted by Christians. His comments highlighted the broader tension between upholding religious convictions and showing compassion in a diverse society.

While some have praised the Gaineses for inclusivity and evolving views, others remain disappointed in what they perceive as a betrayal of Christian principles. The debate underscores ongoing cultural divisions around faith, media, and representation. Despite the criticism, Chip Gaines expressed appreciation for constructive feedback and indicated a willingness to reflect on differing perspectives. As of now, representatives for the Magnolia Network have not responded to media requests for comment.